defguard vs nebula
VPN access management and overlay networking compared
defguard centralizes WireGuard VPN access, identity, and MFA in a self-hosted platform. nebula creates encrypted peer-to-peer overlay networks using certificates; it focuses on connecting hosts and applying group-based traffic rules rather than managing identity services and VPN access together.

defguard: Manage Secure VPN and Identity Access
Defguard is a self-hosted platform for managing WireGuard VPN access, identity, and multi-factor authentication. It suits organizations that want centralized control over network access and authentication inside their own infrastructure.

nebula: Build Secure Peer-to-Peer Overlay Networks
Nebula connects hosts across networks through an encrypted, certificate-based overlay, with group-based traffic rules and peer discovery. It suits teams that need secure connectivity across cloud, datacenter, and endpoint environments without relying on a fixed addressing scheme.
| defguard | nebula | |
|---|---|---|
| Language | Rust | Go |
| License | NOASSERTION | MIT |
| Stars | 2.9k | 18.4k |
| Forks | 119 | 1.2k |
| Last analyzed | Oct 3, 2026 | Oct 3, 2026 |
Key differences
- defguard combines VPN management, authentication, and identity features, while nebula focuses on peer-to-peer connectivity and traffic filtering.
- defguard supports WireGuard locations, device self-service, and per-user or per-group access controls; nebula uses certificates to identify hosts and their groups across an overlay network.
- defguard offers an internal OIDC provider, external OIDC support, and LDAP/AD synchronization; nebula's described identity model uses host certificates and a certificate authority.
- defguard is written in Rust and reports its license as NOASSERTION, with an AGPL open-source core and separately licensed enterprise code; nebula is written in Go and uses the MIT license.
- defguard is self-hosted and requires production deployment planning; nebula requires certificate setup and recommends a routable lighthouse for peer discovery.
- The supplied project figures list 2.9k stars and 119 forks for defguard, compared with 18.4k stars and 1.2k forks for nebula.
Choose defguard if you…
- need centralized WireGuard access management with MFA and identity features.
- want per-user or per-group VPN policies across multiple locations.
- need OIDC or LDAP/AD integration as part of a self-hosted platform.
Choose nebula if you…
- need encrypted peer-to-peer connections across cloud, datacenter, and endpoint networks.
- want certificate-based host identity and group-based traffic rules.
- need a Go-based overlay networking tool with support for a range of platforms.
Compare the numbers side by side, or add more projects
This comparison is generated with AI from the OSRepos analyses of both projects. Always check each project's repository and documentation before choosing.