OrcaReplay vs failproofai
AI agent debugging and runtime controls compared
OrcaReplay and failproofai both capture AI agent activity locally for inspection. OrcaReplay focuses on replaying and forking recorded runs, while failproofai adds policies that can block risky tool calls and offers hosted team observability.

OrcaReplay: Record and Replay AI Agent Runs
OrcaReplay records AI agent runs so developers can inspect what happened, replay interactions offline, and fork a run from a checkpoint onto another model. It is a TypeScript CLI for debugging and comparing agent behavior without modifying the agent.

failproofai: Observe and Enforce AI Agent Runs
FailproofAI is a TypeScript and Rust tool for observing and enforcing AI agent harnesses, including coding CLIs and chat gateways. It captures runs locally and can block tool calls with policies before they execute.
| OrcaReplay | failproofai | |
|---|---|---|
| Language | TypeScript | TypeScript |
| License | Apache-2.0 | — |
| Stars | 274 | 6.9k |
| Forks | 65 | 530 |
| Last analyzed | Oct 4, 2026 | Oct 28, 2026 |
Key differences
- OrcaReplay replays recorded model interactions offline and can fork from a checkpoint; failproofai focuses on observing runs and enforcing policies during execution.
- OrcaReplay traces model requests, tool calls, shell activity, and filesystem changes; failproofai records model and tool calls, policy decisions, and blocked operations.
- OrcaReplay is a TypeScript CLI; failproofai uses TypeScript and Rust, and also provides a Python SDK for tracing and audits.
- OrcaReplay offers local traces, HTML export, JSON output, an MCP server, and a TypeScript API; failproofai includes a local dashboard, offline audits, and hosted team analysis.
- OrcaReplay is Apache-2.0 and described as early, with 274 stars; failproofai's README describes its license as MIT with the Commons Clause, and it has 6.9k stars.
- OrcaReplay requires Node.js 20 or newer; failproofai requires Node.js 20.9 or later and Rust, with enforcement support varying by harness.
Choose OrcaReplay if you…
- need to reproduce agent behavior with offline replay or inspect runs after they end.
- want to compare models on the same task by forking a recorded checkpoint.
- need trace exports or TypeScript tools for accessing and replaying runs.
Choose failproofai if you…
- need policies that can block risky tool calls before they execute.
- want to observe supported coding CLIs and gateways through a local dashboard or hosted team service.
- need tracing and audits for a custom agent through the Python SDK, or enforcement hooks in your own runtime.
Compare the numbers side by side, or add more projects
This comparison is generated with AI from the OSRepos analyses of both projects. Always check each project's repository and documentation before choosing.