Ice vs boring.notch
Mac menu bar tools compared
Ice organizes macOS menu bar items, with hiding, rearranging, appearance controls, and hotkeys. boring.notch turns the area around a MacBook’s notch into a control center for music and utilities, so the main difference is menu bar management versus quick access to selected features.
Ice: Manage and Customize the macOS Menu Bar
Ice is a macOS utility for hiding, arranging, and revealing menu bar items, with controls for menu bar appearance and hotkeys. It suits Mac users who want more control over a crowded menu bar and requires macOS 14 or later.
boring.notch: Add Music Controls and Utilities to the Mac Notch
Boring Notch turns a MacBook’s notch into a compact control center for music, calendar events, reminders, files, and system controls. It suits Mac users who want quick access to these features without switching apps.
| Ice | boring.notch | |
|---|---|---|
| Language | Swift | Swift |
| License | GPL-3.0 | GPL-3.0 |
| Stars | 29.7k | 10.9k |
| Forks | 971 | 1.1k |
| Last analyzed | Oct 3, 2026 | Oct 3, 2026 |
Key differences
- Ice focuses on hiding and arranging menu bar items, while boring.notch brings music, calendar, reminders, files, and system controls into a notch interface.
- Ice offers menu bar appearance settings and hotkeys; boring.notch includes a visualizer, AirDrop file shelf, and replacements for several macOS HUDs.
- Ice requires macOS 14 or later, while building boring.notch from source requires macOS 15.6 or later and Xcode 26 or later.
- Both projects use Swift, have GPL-3.0 licenses, and are not archived.
- Ice has 29.7k stars and 971 forks; boring.notch has 10.9k stars and 1.1k forks.
- Ice marks item spacing as beta and notes some planned features; boring.notch lists weather and Bluetooth live activity among roadmap items not marked complete.
Choose Ice if you…
- need to hide, reveal, or rearrange menu bar items.
- want menu bar appearance controls or hotkeys for managing sections.
- use macOS 14 or later and want a menu bar organizer.
Choose boring.notch if you…
- want music controls, a visualizer, or calendar and reminder information near the notch.
- frequently move files and want a shelf with AirDrop support.
- want notch-integrated controls for volume, brightness, or keyboard backlight.
Compare the numbers side by side, or add more projects
This comparison is generated with AI from the OSRepos analyses of both projects. Always check each project's repository and documentation before choosing.