antonbabenko

deliberation: Get AI Second Opinions Through MCP

Deliberation is a JavaScript MCP server that lets coding agents consult GPT, Gemini, Grok, local models, and OpenRouter models for specialist reviews or arbiter-mediated consensus. It supports Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Kiro, OpenCode, and other MCP hosts.

View on GitHub Compare
Stars
178
Forks
11
Stars, last 30 days
+9
Last commit
10 days ago
Contributors
6

Our take

Newless than six months old and changing fast

Health score

65/100

How it is scored
Activity
77
Community
32
Issues
74
Pull requests
77

+9 stars in the last 30 days

  • Releases more often than 92% of the projects we track
  • Merges more pull requests than 82% of the projects we track
  • Closes issues faster than 81% of the projects we track

Deliberation is a capable, actively changing MCP integration for teams that want structured model review, but its recent pace and concentrated maintenance make it a young project to evaluate before relying on it.

Good fit if

  • Your coding workflow uses Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Kiro, OpenCode, or another MCP host, and you want specialist model reviews.
  • You want an explicit consensus process rather than a single model response, including reasons when critical issues are dismissed.
  • You can meet the provider-specific setup requirements and are comfortable with an MIT-licensed project that is changing quickly.

Look elsewhere if

  • You need a standalone code-review product rather than an MCP server integrated into a coding agent.
  • You require a mature project with broadly distributed maintenance; most contributions come from one person.
  • You want provider access without setting up the required CLIs, credentials, or OpenRouter configuration.
All health signals
Last commit2026-10-15 (10 days ago)
Commits, last 90 days69
Releases, last 12 months96 (latest v3.31.0, 2026-10-15)
Contributors6 (top contributor: 82% of commits)
Issues closed, last 90 days3 (typically closed in 0 days)
Pull requests merged, last 90 days70 (typically merged in 0 days)
Project age6 months

Checked on 2026-10-26 with the GitHub API.

Project history

Daily GitHub snapshots since Oct 7, 2026. History covers stars and forks; health signals are not tracked historically.

Selected snapshot

Stars

186

Forks

12

Change since Nov 17, 2026: +3 stars·0 forks

Overview

Deliberation is a JavaScript MCP server for getting second opinions and mediated consensus from AI models while working with code. It connects coding agents to GPT through the Codex CLI, Gemini through Antigravity CLI, Grok, local models, and models configured through OpenRouter. Seven specialist roles cover tasks such as architecture, code review, security, planning, research, and debugging.

The server works with Claude Code, Codex, Cursor, Kiro, OpenCode, and other MCP hosts. It is aimed at developers who want their coding agent to consult additional models without manually wiring each provider or treating model replies as final answers. In consensus runs, an arbiter coordinates reviews and revisions, with explicit checks against self-approval and unexplained dismissal of critical issues.

Key Features

  • Offers seven domain experts for architecture, plan review, scope analysis, code review, security, research, and debugging.
  • Supports one-shot questions to individual providers or parallel model queries with a synthesized response.
  • Provides an arbiter-mediated consensus loop with blind verdicts, peer review, issue adjudication, and a configurable round limit.
  • Connects to OpenRouter-configured models, including OpenAI-compatible endpoints such as Ollama, vLLM, and LM Studio.
  • Runs as an MCP server across multiple coding-agent hosts, with native plugin artifacts for several hosts.
  • Includes optional session history, run analytics, and a local read-only dashboard for run timelines, provider health, and usage.
  • Supports advisory analysis and Gemini implementation mode, while other experts are read-only.

Use Cases

  • A developer can ask the Security Analyst for a second opinion on an authentication flow before shipping it.
  • A team can use the Plan Reviewer to identify missing assumptions in a migration plan before implementation.
  • When an agent is stuck after repeated debugging attempts, it can request an independent diagnosis from another model.
  • Developers comparing model providers can review run latency, token usage, and verdict agreement with the optional analytics and dashboard.

What you need

Detected in the repository

  • Node.js (from package.json)
  • A Dockerfile, so it can run in a container
  • A test suite and automated checks on GitHub Actions

License in plain words

MITpermissive

  • Commercial use: yes
  • Modify and redistribute: yes
  • You must keep: the copyright and license notice
  • Share your changes: no

A summary, not legal advice: the LICENSE file is what applies.

Getting Started

For Claude Code, install the plugin and run setup:

/plugin marketplace add antonbabenko/agent-plugins
/plugin install deliberation@antonbabenko
/deliberation:setup

For another MCP host, the standalone server is available as @antonbabenko/deliberation-mcp. See the README for provider setup, host-specific instructions, and configuration details.

Alternatives

  • codex-plugin-cc: It delegates code reviews and tasks to a local Codex CLI, rather than coordinating reviews across multiple model providers or seeking arbiter-mediated consensus.
ProjectLanguageLicenseStarsStatus
deliberationJavaScriptMIT178New
codex-plugin-ccJavaScriptApache-2.033.8kQuiet

Considerations

The project is new and changing fast, despite frequent recent commits and releases. Its six contributors are not evenly distributed: most code comes from one person, so maintenance depends substantially on that maintainer. Recent issue handling and merged pull requests indicate active work, but do not remove that concentration risk.

Deliberation requires Node.js and at least one configured provider. GPT and Gemini rely on their respective CLIs and logins, while Grok and OpenRouter require API credentials; OpenRouter models also need configuration. The Docker image does not include the Codex or Antigravity CLIs, so those providers are unavailable inside it. The project is MIT-licensed.

Found this useful?

Share it with someone who would like deliberation.

Comparisons